Statutory media self-regulation : beneficial or detrimental for media freedom?
Title: Statutory media self-regulation : beneficial or detrimental for media freedom?
Author: HULIN, Adeline
Series/Number: EUI RSCAS; 2014/127
In the wake of the British phone hacking scandal of the News of the World, which proved some limits to the model of media self-regulation, a growing number of experts have suggested a statutory recognition of this model by law to improve its performance. At first sight a statutory recognition seems an oxymoron, as the model of media self-regulation – a voluntary system of media regulation independent from public authorities - was originally developed by media professionals themselves to limit state interference in the field of media. Hence, the article explores how statutory recognition is compatible with the concept of media self-regulation. After clarifying the relationships between media regulation, self-regulation and media freedom, the article investigates whether statutory recognition is beneficial or detrimental for media freedom. To answer it, this article draws a distinction between democratic countries and countries in democratic transition. It is argued that statutory media selfregulation in non-democratic countries is problematic because of the risks of transforming selfregulation into a compulsory system controlled by political interests. In democratic countries, statutory media self-regulation can make this voluntary system more effective, for instance by limiting the number of media outlets that decide to abstain from it. However, when statutory recognition is used by state authorities not as a reward but as a punishment for media, it leans towards a two-speed protection of media professionals according to their respect for professional standards or a lack thereof, which is not compatible with the universal nature of freedom of expression.
Subject: Censorship; European public space; Freedom of expression; Media; Media freedom; Media selfregulation; Media regulation; Statutory self-regulation
Type of Access: openAccess; openAccess
Files in this item
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Title:Community media and regulation. Re-writing media policy from a communication for development perspective Author(s):MILAN, StefaniaDate:2007Citation:World Congress on Communication for Development Lessons, Challenges, and the Way Forward, Washington, DC , World Bank Publications, 2007Type:Contribution to book
Title:Migrants and the media in the twenty-first century : obstacles and opportunities for the media to reflect diversity and promote integration Author(s):TRIANDAFYLLIDOU, AnnaDate:2013Citation:Journalism Practice, 2013, Vol. 7, No. 3, pp. 240-247Type:Article
Title:Monitoring media pluralism in Europe : testing and implementation of the media pluralism monitor 2014 Editor(s):BROGI, Elda; DOBREVA, AlinaDate:2015Type:Technical ReportSeries/Number:Centre for Media Pluralism and Media Freedom (CMPF); Policy Report; 2015Abstract:During 2014, the Centre for Media Pluralism and Media Freedom (CMPF) carried out a pilot-test implementation of an updated and streamlined version of the Media Pluralism Monitor (MPM) developed in 2009 by a consortium led ...