Publication
Open Access

Unwilling or unable? : assessing the failure of the Rule of Law framework and article 7 TEU in Poland

Thumbnail Image
License
Full-text via DOI
ISBN
ISSN
Issue Date
Type of Publication
Keyword(s)
LC Subject Heading
Other Topic(s)
EUI Research Cluster(s)
Initial version
Published version
Succeeding version
Preceding version
Published version part
Earlier different version
Initial format
Citation
Durham : Durham University, 2021
Durham University; Faculty of Social Sciences and Health; Department of Law; Master Thesis
Cite
POLAŃSKI, Oskar, Unwilling or unable? : assessing the failure of the Rule of Law framework and article 7 TEU in Poland, Durham : Durham University, 2021, Durham University, Faculty of Social Sciences and Health, Department of Law, Master Thesis - https://hdl.handle.net/1814/74066
Abstract
Since 2015 the Prawo i Sprawiedliwość (PiS) government in Poland has engaged in a process of rule of law backsliding, viz., it has eroded various forms of checks and balances in order to entrench itself in power. It has, inter alia, disabled effective judicial review, replaced judges in courts across the country, and introduced a disciplinary regime for recalcitrant judges. This process poses a threat to the very existence and functioning of the European Union: by controlling the judiciary, the regime can pick and choose which EU laws will be complied with. Such selective compliance undermines fundamental concepts upon which the very functioning of the EU’s legal order is based such as, inter alia, mutual trust, autonomy, and supremacy. However, despite this threat, the EU’s institutions have thus far been unable – or unwilling – to adequately resolve this crisis. By considering the implementation of the Rule of Law Framework and Article 7 TEU, this thesis will present four key lessons the EU must adhere to in its future dealings with backsliding Member States. Namely, the EU must resort to hard enforcement; be responsive to the time-sensitivity of backsliding; ensure its tools are accessible; and avoid leaving the protection of its values solely to the protection of intergovernmental institutions. These lessons are believed to be integral to neutralising the threat posed by backsliding and persevering the integrity of the EU’s legal order.
Table of Contents
Additional Information
Thesis awarded when author already at the EUI Law department.
Version
Research Projects
Sponsorship and Funder Information
Collections