Decoding judicial cross-citations : how do European judges engage with foreign case law?

Simple item page
dc.contributor.authorDE WITTE, Folker Andries
dc.contributor.authorKRISZTIÁN, Anna
dc.contributor.authorKUKAVICA, Jaka
dc.contributor.authorPOTOCKA-SIONEK, Nastazja
dc.contributor.authorSIEMS, Mathias
dc.contributor.authorYIATROU, Vasiliki
dc.date.accessioned2025-05-12T13:07:10Z
dc.date.available2025-05-12T13:07:10Z
dc.date.issued2024
dc.descriptionPublished online: 28 September 2024
dc.description.abstractHow do judges engage with foreign case law? While prior research has identified some instances of courts willing to cite foreign judgments, details about the mode of engagement and the motivation of such cross-citations have often been left unexplored. This Article fills these gaps. It presents the results of the coding of a sample of 456 judgments with cross-citations between the private law supreme courts of twenty-eight European countries. Twenty-five variables were coded for each citation: for example, the length of the discussion of foreign case law, whether the court was interested in the result or the reasoning of foreign judgments, and whether the citations occurred within the context of EU law, international law and/or specific areas of the law. This Article presents and contextualizes (i.e., “decodes”) this quantitative information. Amongst others, we find that courts from common law countries more often cite older foreign case law and provide a greater depth of engagement with it than courts from civil law countries, that many of the courts are mainly interested in the result and not the reasoning of foreign judgments, that most cross-citations are driven by reasons of comparative law (and not, for example, EU law or international law), and that cross-citations due to EU law are particularly prevalent in IP law and conflict of laws. More generally, we observe a form of bifurcation of citations across many of the topics analyzed, suggesting a divide, not between common and civil law countries, but between courts from smaller and larger jurisdictions (e.g., with smaller jurisdictions using citations in more traditional areas of law, citing mainly one other court, citing older cases, and more often being interested in the reasoning of foreign judgments).
dc.description.versionPublished version of EUI LAW WP 2022/12
dc.identifier.citationThe American journal of comparative law, 2024, Vol. 72, No. 2, pp. 380-427
dc.identifier.doi10.1093/ajcl/avae021
dc.identifier.endpage427
dc.identifier.issn0002-919X
dc.identifier.issn2326-9197
dc.identifier.issue2
dc.identifier.startpage380
dc.identifier.urihttps://hdl.handle.net/1814/92621
dc.identifier.volume72
dc.language.isoen
dc.orcid.putcode1814/79984:185074202
dc.orcid.putcode1814/79395:185074203
dc.orcid.putcode1814/79854:185074204
dc.orcid.putcode1814/79611:185074205
dc.orcid.putcode1814/80947:185074206
dc.publisherOxford University Press
dc.relation.ispartofThe American journal of comparative law
dc.relation.isversionofhttps://hdl.handle.net/1814/75110
dc.titleDecoding judicial cross-citations : how do European judges engage with foreign case law?
dc.typeArticle
dspace.entity.typePublication
person.identifier.orcid0000-0001-5439-1009
person.identifier.orcid0000-0001-8213-5045
person.identifier.orcid0000-0002-7346-6683
person.identifier.orcid0000-0001-9841-5068
person.identifier.orcid0000-0001-5872-945X
person.identifier.other44345
person.identifier.other40997
person.identifier.other43557
person.identifier.other42539
person.identifier.other29588
person.identifier.other44294
relation.isAuthorOfPublication00a08d8d-e0cd-4e65-b82e-ea2663b1c446
relation.isAuthorOfPublicationa16cc93d-e300-4361-9a2a-3ea0bcce50b8
relation.isAuthorOfPublication5085ce5e-e78d-43e8-a9c7-bed4e74ff253
relation.isAuthorOfPublication008507d4-48f0-4da8-9880-1b1aa41e761c
relation.isAuthorOfPublication3dc7bdb8-2ee8-4ac9-972c-fa7aa74ce05d
relation.isAuthorOfPublication8c4b1ef9-e299-48b3-aab2-ed5952b16d12
relation.isAuthorOfPublication.latestForDiscoverya16cc93d-e300-4361-9a2a-3ea0bcce50b8
Files
License bundle
Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
Thumbnail Image
Name:
license.txt
Size:
4.14 KB
Format:
Item-specific license agreed upon to submission
Description:
Download
Collections
LAW Articles