Article 4 of the European Media Freedom Act : a missed opportunity? : assessing its shortcomings in protecting journalistic sources

KERMER, Jan Erik

Article 4 of the European Media Freedom Act : a missed opportunity? : assessing its shortcomings in protecting journalistic sources

dc.contributor.author	KERMER, Jan Erik
dc.date.accessioned	2024-11-15T11:04:32Z
dc.date.available	2024-11-15T11:04:32Z
dc.date.issued	2024
dc.description	Published online: 09 September 2024	en
dc.description.abstract	Article 4 of the recently approved European Media Freedom Act (EMFA) aims, first and foremost, to protect journalists as well as safeguarding their sources by prohibiting or at the very least limiting the use of state surveillance technology. Despite its apparently good intentions, there are several potential loopholes and shortcomings of this Article which are laid out in this paper. To begin with, Article 4 essentially legalises the use of spyware in EU law, albeit under exceptional circumstances. In addition, the provision permitting the retrospective authorisation of spyware opens up the possibility of journalists’ rights being violated before the intervention of the law. The Article, furthermore, affords too much discretion for EU governments to deploy spyware. To compound matters, expanding the list of “serious crimes” to offences such as intellectual property theft and piracy is disproportionate when weighed against the fundamental rights at stake. The scope, moreover, includes crimes carrying a custodial sentence of 5 years, as defined solely under national law, thus undermining the original purpose of EMFA, which is to harmonise national regulatory systems related to the media. Most concerning, however, is the loophole in this Article which fails to outlaw surveillance outsourcing to private entities. In sum, EMFA affords too much discretion for states to deploy draconian surveillance measures that ultimately threaten journalistic sources. To conclude, recommendations are elaborated to overcome the limitations and risks previously analysed.	en
dc.format.mimetype	application/pdf	en
dc.identifier.citation	Kaloyan SIMEONOV and Mariya YURUKOVA (eds), Papers from the Eleventh International Scientific Conference of the European Studies Department : the agenda of the new EU institutional cycle, Sofia : Minerva, 2024, pp. 192-207	en
dc.identifier.isbn	9789548702645
dc.identifier.uri	https://hdl.handle.net/1814/77470
dc.language.iso	en	en
dc.orcid.upload	true	*
dc.publisher	Minerva	en
dc.relation.ispartofseries	[Centre for Media Pluralism and Media Freedom (CMPF)]	en
dc.relation.uri	https://www.martenscentre.eu/publication/the-agenda-of-the-new-eu-institutional-cycle/	en
dc.rights	info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess	en
dc.title	Article 4 of the European Media Freedom Act : a missed opportunity? : assessing its shortcomings in protecting journalistic sources	en
dc.type	Contribution to book	en
dspace.entity.type	Publication
eui.subscribe.skip	true
person.identifier.orcid	0000-0002-1017-6590
person.identifier.other	52719
relation.isAuthorOfPublication	5b401160-2a5b-4537-9aa5-1dcc1d3d6cf3
relation.isAuthorOfPublication.latestForDiscovery	5b401160-2a5b-4537-9aa5-1dcc1d3d6cf3