Open Access
Historical revisionism in comparative perspective : law, politics and surrogate mourning
Loading...
Files
LAW_2013_12.pdf (622.68 KB)
LAW 2013/12
License
Cadmus Permanent Link
Full-text via DOI
ISBN
ISSN
1725-6739
Issue Date
Type of Publication
LC Subject Heading
Other Topic(s)
EUI Research Cluster(s)
Initial version
Published version
Succeeding version
Preceding version
Published version part
Earlier different version
Initial format
Author(s)
Citation
EUI LAW; 2013/12
Cite
BELAVUSAU, Uladzislau, Historical revisionism in comparative perspective : law, politics and surrogate mourning, EUI LAW, 2013/12 - https://hdl.handle.net/1814/29099
Abstract
Recently the law on the Armenian genocide denial in France with a subsequent decision of the Conseil Constitutionnel (February 2012) shed fresh light on the controversial issue of historical revisionism. It disposed the issue in a wider perspective than a recurrent legal discussion on Holocaust denial. Furthermore, in drawing their bill, the authors of the French law invoked the EU Council Framework Decision 2008/913. This article demonstrates the chilling effects of that EU instrument for the freedom of speech in Europe. To these ends, it first explores the “European” model of legal engagement with historiography that is radically different from its counterpart in the USA. It further places this model in a fertile yet under-theorized comparative realm of three Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries: the Czech Republic, Hungary, and Poland. The CEE is a primary arena of the Holocaust, a region particularly sensitive to interpretations of World War II, and a battlefield of two totalitarian regimes. In normative terms, this comparative study of semantic and pragmatic differences between historical revisionism and hate speech, of victimhood and mens rea in the crime of Holocaust denial, as well as of the appropriation of selected episodes of World War II, concludes that the criminalization of historical revisionism constitutes a substantial impairment to the freedom of (academic) expression for the sake of politics of memory (Geschichtspolitik).
Table of Contents
0. Introduction -- 1. Normative perspective on historical revisionism -- 2. Historical revisionism in European law : status and recent developments -- 3. Historical revisionism in Central and Eastern Europe -- 4. Conclusions : towards the ethics of memory via free speech