The good, the bad, and the ugly : lessons on methodology in legal analysis from the recent WTO litigation on renewable energy subsidies
License
Cadmus Permanent Link
Full-text via DOI
ISBN
ISSN
1011-6702
Issue Date
Type of Publication
Keyword(s)
LC Subject Heading
Other Topic(s)
EUI Research Cluster(s)
Initial version
Published version
Succeeding version
Preceding version
Published version part
Earlier different version
Initial format
Author(s)
Citation
Journal of world trade, 2014, Vol. 48, No. 5, pp. 895-936
[Global Governance Programme]; [Global Economics]
Cite
RUBINI, Luca, The good, the bad, and the ugly : lessons on methodology in legal analysis from the recent WTO litigation on renewable energy subsidies, Journal of world trade, 2014, Vol. 48, No. 5, pp. 895-936, [Global Governance Programme], [Global Economics] - https://hdl.handle.net/1814/39517
Abstract
Through the use of the recent litigation on renewable energy subsidies in the World Trade Organization ('WTO') as a case study, this article highlights the importance of methodology in legal analysis and, in particular, of integrity, coherence, and legitimacy. Reference is made to those cases where, in the presence of pressing policy considerations, the adjudicator is led to commit serious errors in order to reach what is perceived as a just and desirable outcome. Adjudicators are often called to distinguish a 'good' policy from a 'bad' one but, if the regulatory framework is not sufficiently responsive to such distinctions, the act of accommodation of law and policy may lead to 'ugly' constructions of the law. The twist of this course of conduct is that the effects of legal interpretation tweaking might not be easily confined to the case at hand and may have broader, negative implications for the legal system at large. Rather than resolving into a simple criticism of adjudicating bodies, the article argues that the ultimate responsibility for dispute settlement mistakes caused by policy pressures is that of law-makers and their inability to take the lead and reform the law.