History, action and identity: revisiting the 'second' great debate and assessing its importance for social theory
European journal of international relations, 2006, 12, 1, 5-29
KRATOCHWIL, Friedrich, History, action and identity: revisiting the 'second' great debate and assessing its importance for social theory, European journal of international relations, 2006, 12, 1, 5-29 - https://hdl.handle.net/1814/17471
Retrieved from Cadmus, EUI Research Repository
This article raises the issue about the nature of knowledge in practical matters. Traditionally this question has been answered by pointing to 'theory-building' and to field independent epistemological criteria that are supposed to provide the knowledge warrants for the assertions made within a theoretical framework. In this context universality, i.e. generality and trans-historical reliability of the 'data', are particularly powerful criteria that establish the `truth' of theoretical propositions through 'tests' and thus contribute to cumulative 'knowledge'. But this ideal of 'theoretical' knowledge significantly misunderstands both the type of knowledge we need when we make practical choices and that of 'history' in constituting us as agents. In using Bull's argument in the second debate as a foil, and in revisiting also the controversies concerning the democratic peace and the role of macro-historical studies I first elaborate on the nature of the 'historicity' and situatedness of all practical knowledge. In a second step, I attempt to clarify how the knowledge of the past relates to practical choices in that 'history' is not simply a storehouse of fixed data, but a product of memory, which in turn is deeply involved in our constructions of identity and of the political projects we pursue. In a third step I adumbrate the criteria for knowledge generation that are more appropriate when we face practical problems.
Cadmus permanent link: https://hdl.handle.net/1814/17471
Full-text via DOI: 10.1177/1354066106061323
Keyword(s): Social theory Knowledge Epistemology Agency Conflict theory Memory History Identity formation
Files associated with this item
There are no files associated with this item.